V.L. ENTERPRISE PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: VL🇹🇭 TH

Board Performance · 2024

Compliance Monitoring — Overview

Compliance Monitoring — Introduction

Monitoring compliance with corporate governance policies and practices. V.L. Enterprise Public Company Limited is an organization committed to conducting business under good corporate governance principles. It has excellent management, ethics, transparency, accountability, and is free from corruption. It focuses on maximizing shareholder value and considers all stakeholders. The company has adopted the good corporate governance principles of the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) as guidelines for good corporate governance practices that are in line with the company's operations. The first edition of the Good Corporate Governance Handbook was issued in 2018 (CG Code 2017) for the Board of Directors, executives, and employees to follow as guidelines for working to create sustainable value for the business.


In addition to building confidence among shareholders and investors, the Board of Directors has established corporate governance guidelines to lead to the creation of competitiveness and outstanding performance. This takes into account long-term impacts, fair and ethical business practices, respect for rights, and responsibility to society, the environment, health, safety in the organization, and treating all stakeholder groups equally.

Prevention of Conflicts of Interest

Has the Company Acted to Prevent Conflicts of Interest?

Yes

Operations in the Past Year

The Company has established a related party transaction policy and a code of business conduct and ethics to encourage the Board of Directors, management, and employees to perform their duties in the best interests of the Company.


The Company will obtain an opinion from the Audit Committee on the necessity and appropriateness of such transactions, or the auditor will provide an opinion on such related party transactions to the Audit Committee for the Audit Committee to use in making its decision and providing an opinion to the Board of Directors or shareholders, as the case may be, to approve such transactions prior to entering into the transactions.


The approval of such related party transactions must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, whereby those who may have conflicts of interest or have an interest in the related party transactions will not have the right to vote on such transactions. In the past year, the Company has reviewed cases that may give rise to conflicts of interest, with the following conclusions:

•Related party transactions in businesses that may have conflicts of interest between the Company and individuals who are authorized directors, the Chief Executive Officer, and major shareholders involve the lease of buildings to be used as the head office in Bangkok and the office in Si Racha District, Chonburi Province. The transactions have passed the size of transaction review by the auditor, received approval for the reasonableness of the transactions from the Audit Committee, and received approval for the transactions from the Board of Directors.


•The review of the Board of Directors' tenure found that no director holds a position in other businesses that operate in the same industry or have competing characteristics.

Number of Conflict-of-Interest Cases

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of cases or issues related to conflicts of interest (cases)000

Prevention of the Use of Inside Information

Has the Company Acted to Prevent the Use of Inside Information?

Yes

Operations in the Past Year

The Company recognizes and places importance on operating under the principles of Good Corporate Governance, including checks and balances, and recognizes the significance of using the Company's inside information for personal gain. The Board of Directors and management have therefore established measures to control and monitor the use of the Company's inside information by issuing policies to prevent insider trading and reporting of securities holdings to ensure that the Company operates transparently in accordance with good corporate governance principles.


• Prohibit directors, executives, or employees of the Company who are aware of inside information from disclosing such information to outsiders or unauthorized persons. Prohibit such personnel from trading in the Company's shares during the one-month period before the Company discloses its financial statements or other material information to the public.


• Have a company secretary monitor and notify the Board of Directors, executives, and four levels of management, as defined by the SEC's Notification on the Definition of the Announcement on the Issuance and Offering of Securities, to refrain from trading in the Company's shares during the one-month period before the Company discloses its financial statements. They must also report changes in shareholdings and futures trading to the SEC through the electronic data submission system as specified by the SEC or by any other means specified by the SEC.

Number of Inside-Information Cases

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of cases or issues related to the use of inside information to seek benefits (cases)000

Anti-Corruption

Has the Company Acted on Anti-Corruption?

Yes

Operations in the Past Year

The company is committed to conducting business with honesty, transparency, and in accordance with good corporate governance principles. We oppose all forms of corruption, recognizing its serious threat to free and fair competition and its detrimental impact on economic and social development. The Anti-Corruption Policy ("Policy") is an integral part of the company's Code of Business Conduct and was approved by the Board of Directors in its meeting no. 1/2561 on September 18, 2018. It has been published on the company's website www.vltanker.com

In addition, all employees must be trained or tested on their knowledge and understanding of anti-corruption. New employees must undergo training on this matter before being employed or at the first available training opportunity. In the past year, 100% of the company's employees have completed the training. Disciplinary actions are determined in accordance with the company's employee disciplinary regulations and/or relevant laws.

Form of Anti-Corruption Operations

Operation
Review of the completeness and adequacy of the process by the Audit Committee or auditor

Number of Corruption Cases

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of cases or issues related to corruption (cases)000

Whistleblowing

Has the Company Implemented Whistleblowing Procedures?

Yes

Operations in the Past Year

The company has opened channels for employees, customers, or external parties to report clues, suggestions, or complaints regarding fraud or any actions that do not comply with the company's regulations. Stakeholders can submit their reports, along with credible information and details, in writing. They may choose to remain anonymous or disclose their identity. The reports should be submitted to the Audit Committee through whistleblowing@vltanker.com      


In 2024, there were no reports or complaints related to fraud or violations of the company's corporate governance policies.

Number of Whistleblowing Cases

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of cases or issues received through whistleblowing channels (cases)000

Selection of Directors & Chief Executives

Are Directors Selected Through the Nomination Committee?

Yes

Are Chief Executives Selected Through the Nomination Committee?

Yes

Number of Directors from Major Shareholders

2

Rights of Minority Shareholders on Director Appointment

The company allows shareholders to propose meeting agendas in advance and nominate individuals to serve as directors to be included as an agenda item for the annual shareholders' meeting from December 15, 2023, to January 15, 2024, with details announced on the company's website.

Method of Director Appointment

Method
Method whereby each director requires approval votes more than half of the votes of attending shareholders with voting rights

Selection of Independent Directors

Criteria for Selecting Independent Directors

Recruitment by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee


1.1.1 Consider and review the structure and qualifications of the Board of Directors to be appropriate and consistent with the company's business operations.


1.1.2 Consider the criteria and process for recruiting qualified individuals to serve as directors, including selecting individuals according to the established recruitment process, and submit recommendations to the Board of Directors for consideration when such positions become vacant, which may require submission to the shareholders' meeting for approval.


1.1.1.1 Consider the list of directors whose terms are expiring and the list of persons nominated for election as directors of the company, both from the nominations of directors and shareholders of the company, especially minority shareholders (if any).

1.1.1.2 Consider that a person nominated to be a director of the company must not possess any prohibited characteristics or qualifications as prescribed by law, including the regulations and good practices of the SEC.

1.1.1.3 Consider that a person nominated to be a director of the company must have knowledge, skills, experience, and expertise that are beneficial to the company, have leadership qualities, a broad vision, dedicate time and effort to perform their duties fairly, be straightforward, have the courage to express their opinions, have a good and untarnished work history, and have good ethics.

1.1.1.4 Consider that a person nominated to be a director of the company must not engage in any business that is of the same nature and competes with the company's business, whether for their own benefit or for the benefit of others.

1.1.1.5 The director recruitment process may utilize consulting firms or director databases to search for new directors.


1.1.4 Consider and establish a succession plan for directors and managing directors, including determining the criteria for considering successors and submitting recommendations to the Board of Directors for approval.


1.1.5 Perform any other actions as assigned by the Board of Directors regarding the recruitment of directors and executives of the company.


Did Any Independent Director Have a Business or Professional Relationship?

No

Evaluation of Board & Subcommittee Performance

Criteria for Evaluating Board Performance

Performance Evaluation of the Board of Directors, Subcommittees, and Senior Management


The company shall have the Board of Directors and subcommittees conduct a self-evaluation of their performance, both collectively and individually, at least once a year. This evaluation serves as a framework for reviewing the performance of the Board of Directors during the past year to determine whether they have fully and appropriately performed their duties and responsibilities in accordance with the principles of good corporate governance. The performance evaluation of the subcommittees includes the Audit Committee, the Compensation and Nomination Committee, the Corporate Governance and Sustainability Committee, and the Risk Management Committee.


The Board of Directors' performance evaluation utilizes an assessment form developed in line with the Stock Exchange of Thailand's guidelines, adapted to suit the characteristics and structure of the Board. The evaluation results will be instrumental in developing the Board's performance and operations to be more efficient and effective.


The Board's self-assessment consists of 6 topics:

• Structure and Qualifications of the Board of Directors

• Roles, Duties, and Responsibilities of the Board of Directors

• Board of Directors Meeting

• Performance of Directors

• Relationship with Management

• Board Development


The Board's self-assessment consists of 5 topics:

• Structure and Qualifications of the Board of Directors

• Roles, Duties, and Responsibilities of the Board of Directors

• Board of Directors Meeting

• Performance of Directors

• Relationship with Management


The subcommittee's self-assessment consists of 4 topics:

• Structure and Qualifications of the Board of Directors

• Board of Directors Meeting

• Roles, Duties, and Responsibilities of the Board of Directors

• Reporting of Subcommittees


The scoring method involves each director indicating their opinion by marking (/) in one of the score boxes ranging from 0-4 on the evaluation form. The score levels range from "Strongly Disagree" or "No Action Taken" to "Strongly Agree" or "Excellent Implementation." The total score is then calculated as a percentage of the total score, which is defined as follows:


• A score of 95 percent or higher is considered "Excellent."

• A score of 85 percent or higher is considered "Very Good."

• A score of 75 percent or higher is considered "Good."

• A score of 65 percent or higher is considered "Fair."

• A score of 55 percent or higher is considered "Should Improve."


Process

The company secretary will send the performance evaluation form to all directors for self-assessment at the end of each year. After each director has completed the evaluation, the evaluation form will be returned to the company secretary for compilation of the evaluation scores. A summary report will be presented to the Board of Directors meeting to determine measures to improve the effectiveness of the Board's work.

Evaluation of Board Performance in the Past Year

The Board of Directors' self-assessment results for the year 2567 (2024) show an average score of 99.54%, which is considered "Excellent."

Scores by Evaluation Criteria

1. Board Structure and Qualifications received an evaluation score of 99.07%, which is considered very good.

2. Roles, Responsibilities, and Accountabilities of the Board of Directors received an evaluation score of 99.12%, which is considered excellent.

3. Board Meetings received an evaluation score of 99.07%, which is considered excellent.

4. Directors' Performance received an evaluation score of 100%, which is considered excellent.

5. Relationship with Management received an evaluation score of 100%, which is considered excellent.

6. Self-Development of Directors and Executives received an evaluation score of 100%, which is considered excellent.


Comments / Additional Suggestions from Self-Assessment

-none-

Evaluation Results

Evaluated BodyGroup — Carried Out?Group — Grade / Average ScoreGroup — Grade / Full ScoreIndividual (Self-Assessment) — Carried Out?Individual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Average ScoreIndividual (Self-Assessment) — Grade / Full ScoreCross (Assessing Other Directors) — Carried Out?
Board Of DirectorY99.54100Y99.68100N
Audit CommitteeY99.83100NN
Other SubcommitteeY98.75100NN
Other SubcommitteeY98.44100NN
Other SubcommitteeY99.83100NN

Subcommittees

Subcommittees

Results of the Subcommittee's Duty Performance

In 2024, the Board of Directors approved the restructuring of the Nomination and Remuneration Committee to comprise a majority of independent directors in accordance with good corporate governance principles, and The Board of Directors has resolved to allow the Company to provide shareholders with the opportunity to propose meeting agendas and nominate individuals to serve as directors from December 15, 2024, to January 15, 2025. Details have been announced on the Company's website, and a shareholder, Bongkot Holdings Company Limited, has proposed the following agenda and list of individuals to become directors:


• Propose meeting agendas.

1. Consider and approve the appointment of 3 new directors to the Company's Board of Directors.


• Nominate individuals for election as company directors.

1. Ms. Sirisa Supawasin

2. Ms. Wimonwan Jaysrichai

3. Mr. Nopphong Rattanachaiphornphan

Therefore, the Board of Directors considered inviting the nominated individuals to the selection process by inviting them for an interview to present their vision, qualifications, knowledge, skills, experience, and expertise beneficial to the company. This also includes their work history, leadership, integrity, fairness, ethical conduct, and the absence of prohibited characteristics as stipulated by law. The Board will then present their recommendations to the Board of Directors for approval to be proposed at the Shareholders' Meeting for consideration and approval.


Furthermore, the Board of Directors has considered and established fair and appropriate remuneration policies and guidelines for the Company's Board of Directors and employees, which have been approved by the Board of Directors' Meeting.

Over the past year, the Risk Management Committee has prioritized monitoring risk management to ensure its effectiveness, appropriateness, and timeliness in response to the increasingly rapid changes in the current environment. Consequently, the meeting resolution deemed it necessary to establish a Risk Management Working Group to closely monitor and assess risks. Additionally, guidelines for the Committee's operations were established, mandating at least one Committee meeting per quarter. The Risk Management Working Group was appointed to monitor, control, and assess risks based on potential events. This Working Group is required to report on its risk management performance to the Committee quarterly. Therefore, responsibilities were divided into two levels:

1. Organizational Level

2. Operational Level


In 2024, the Risk Management Committee was restructured to comprise the entire Board of Directors, with independent directors constituting a majority in accordance with corporate governance principles. The development and implementation of the Crisis Preparedness Management Plan were successfully completed and became effective on October 31, 2024. Furthermore, the consideration of sustainability risks related to "ESG" issues, also known as "ESG Risk," was incorporated to align with the organization's sustainability policy. This involved providing opportunities for employees from all departments to participate in risk assessments and organizing training sessions on "Risk Management & ESG for Business Excellence." These sessions aimed to enhance knowledge about risk management and foster a risk management culture throughout the organization, targeting the Board of Directors, senior management, and employees comprehensively.

The performance of the Corporate Governance and Sustainable Development Committee, the position of Chairman of the Corporate Governance and Social Responsibility Committee, has elevated the performance by providing policies and guidelines for the Committee's work. It has ordered the establishment of a working group to oversee good corporate governance and sustainable development to monitor and implement concrete actions. The Committee has provided guidance on following good corporate governance principles. To enable the Committee to monitor the performance of the working group as assigned, it has been determined that meetings should be held at least twice a year.


In 2024, the Board of Directors approved the Company's declaration of intent to join the Collective Action Coalition of Thai Private Sector Against Corruption (CAC) and established operational guidelines on social responsibility, the environment, and good corporate governance. The company has arranged for both short-term and long-term project plans for the sustainability of the business and all stakeholders.

Meeting Attendance & Remuneration

Types of Remuneration of the Board of Directors

• The Company pays remuneration to all directors who are not permanent employees and attend meetings in person.


• Remuneration of Individual Directors: The monetary compensation of the directors, as per the resolution of the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders held on April 19, 1967, approved the remuneration of directors for the year 1967 according to the attached schedule. Directors who are also executives will not receive meeting attendance fees or annual bonuses but will receive an annual bonus in accordance with company regulations.


• Annual Remuneration: The Shareholders' Meeting resolved to set the annual remuneration for directors in 2024 at a maximum of 1.5 million baht.



Remuneration or Benefits Payable to the Board

MetricAmount (Baht)
Remunerations or benefits pending payment to the board of directors over the past year (baht)0

Supervision of Subsidiaries & Associated Companies

Does the Company Have Subsidiaries or Associated Companies?

No

Is There a Mechanism for Overseeing Subsidiaries and Associated Companies?

No

Mechanism for Overseeing Management of Subsidiaries

The company has no subsidiaries and associated companies.

Agreements Between the Company and Shareholders in Managing Subsidiaries

The company has no subsidiaries and associated companies.

Board Duty Performance — Overview

Board Duty Performance — Overall Description

Performance of the Board of Directors in 2024

The Board of Directors plays a crucial role in overseeing the Company's operations, fostering confidence among shareholders and all stakeholders. Each Director performs their duties with responsibility, integrity, and diligence to safeguard the Company's best interests. They ensure compliance with laws, the Company's objectives, articles of association, and shareholder resolutions. Acting with integrity and prudence, they protect the Company's interests and ensure its adherence to all relevant laws and regulations governing its business operations, including those prohibiting bribery and supporting anti-corruption measures.


This includes approving business policies, objectives, operational plans, business strategies, and annual budgets. It also encompasses monitoring and supervising the management and organization of the executive team to ensure the effective implementation of established policies, plans, and budgets. The Board also oversees risk management (Risk Management) across the organization, providing insights and recommendations that benefit the Company.

Audit Committee Duty Performance

Results of the Audit Committee's Duty Performance in the Past Year

The Audit Committee, a crucial mechanism for good corporate governance, operates independently to ensure that the company's operations are within the framework of good corporate governance. It has considered various important matters, covering the scope and responsibilities according to the charter, as follows:


1. Supervision of Internal Audit Operations and the Adequacy of the Company's Internal Control System: The Audit Committee considers the appropriateness of the internal control system audit plan and the scope of work covering all departments to ensure that the audit plan and scope of duties will enable the company to have an internal control system and accounting system that are adequate in preventing fraud and various irregularities. In the past year, the company hired an external internal audit service provider, A.M.T. Solution Co., Ltd., to audit and review the internal control system on a quarterly basis for a total of 4 times. Each quarter, the auditor will issue a report, present it to the management, and report the internal audit results to the Audit Committee meeting for approval.


2. Supervision of the Company's Financial Reporting: The Audit Committee places importance on the auditor's duty to maintain independence in auditing the company's financial statements to ensure transparency in the company's financial statement audit. It also considers the scope of the auditor's duties, accounting principles and practices, compliance with accounting standards, and changes in significant accounting policies. In the past year, the Audit Committee approved the appointment of the auditing firm, Dharmniti Audit Co., Ltd., as the company's auditor, conducting quarterly audits three times and an annual audit once. Ms. Thanyaphorn Tangtanopajai, Certified Auditor No. 9169, served as the company's auditor, with an audit fee of 1,100,000 Baht. The auditor regularly reported the financial statement audit to the Audit Committee.


3. Communication of Important Matters between the Audit Committee and the Auditor: The Audit Committee provides opportunities for the auditor to report on problems or limitations encountered during the financial statement audit, changes in accounting policies that may affect the company's operations, as well as new financial instruments or newly enforced laws to enable the Audit Committee to be aware of potential future impacts and to establish guidelines for the company's operations in compliance with laws and regulations.


4. The Audit Committee is of the opinion that the audit team and other personnel in the auditing firm and its network offices have complied with the auditor's code of ethics, which does not affect the auditor's independence in auditing the company's financial statements.


5. Other Duties of the Audit Committee: The Audit Committee regularly reviews related party transactions that may present conflicts of interest to ensure that such transactions are reasonable and in the best interest of the company. In 2024, the Audit Committee performed its duties and provided opinions cautiously for related party transactions that occurred. The size of the related party transactions was considered and benchmarked to ensure reasonableness for the company's business operations.

Executive Committee Duty Performance

Results of the Executive Committee's Duty Performance in the Past Year

The Executive Committee has held regular meetings throughout the past year to deliberate on crucial company matters, ensuring alignment with established objectives. This includes the consideration of strategic adjustments across various aspects. Notably, the year 2567 (2024) presented significant challenges that profoundly impacted the company's management and operations, necessitating operational adaptations and the exploration of new avenues to maximize benefits. To prevent potential irregularities, rigorous monitoring, oversight, and communication have been implemented, emphasizing vigilance and consistent scrutiny. Significant occurrences are routinely reported to the Board of Directors' meetings for their awareness, and directives or recommendations from the Board are diligently executed.

Contents